Why two similar jobs can cost very different amounts

People are often caught out when two builders price the same job far apart, or when a friend's extension came in well under theirs. Usually nobody is pulling a fast one. The jobs only look the same.

A building price is a price for one house, on one plot, built in one order by one team. The same loft conversion on a 1930s semi and on a 1990s estate house can need a different roof structure, a different stair and different fire protection. A garden room on a flat lawn and one on a slope need different bases. The drawing might be identical. The job isn't.

So instead of a figure, this guide sets out the things that decide the price of any building job. They're the questions we ask ourselves when we price building work, including knock-throughs, extensions, conversions and new houses. If you're pricing an extension in particular, what sets the cost of a house extension takes one apart layer by layer.

How settled is the design?

The more that's decided before a builder prices the job, the closer the quote will be to what you end up paying. A quote from finished drawings, an engineer's calculations and a chosen specification can be a firm price for most of the work. A quote from a sketch has to guess, and guesses are either padded or optimistic.

Three things are worth settling first:

  • Structure. Get the engineer's calculations done. A builder pricing steel without them is pricing the biggest steel they think you might need.
  • Finishes. Bricks, roof covering, windows, flooring, the kitchen. If you haven't chosen, the quote has to carry an allowance, and allowances are where final bills drift.
  • Who's doing what. If you're buying the kitchen or using your own electrician, say so, so it's left out rather than priced twice.

Changes once work starts cost more than the same change on paper. Something already built has to come out, materials already ordered may not go back, and the programme shifts for every trade behind it. That isn't a builder being awkward. It's the reason to settle the design first.

Why does building work seem so expensive?

Because most of it is skilled labour, done once, on a site that has to be set up from nothing. A factory makes the same kitchen unit thousands of times. A builder makes your extension once, outdoors, around your house and your family.

A good part of any price is things you never see in the finished room: scaffolding, skips and waste, protecting the house and next door's side, temporary props, toilets and welfare for the trades, deliveries, setting out, and the hours spent getting levels, lines and junctions right before anything is covered up.

There's responsibility too. When one contractor runs your job, the client's Building Regulations duties and site safety duties pass to them by law. Planning the work, checking each trade is competent for what they take on and keeping the site safe all take time, and it's time worth paying for.

None of that makes every high price fair. But a quote that's well below the others usually has one of those things missing, and it's worth finding out which one.

Access and the site

How materials get in and waste gets out makes a real difference. A detached house with a wide drive takes a lorry, a skip and a pallet of blocks at the front door. A mid terrace with no rear access means every bag of plaster and length of timber is carried through the house, and the soil from the footings goes out the same way, a barrow at a time.

Other things on the list: where a skip or a delivery can go, whether there's anywhere for the trades to park, how close the neighbours are, whether the scaffold has to stand on next door's land, and trees or overhead cables in the way. None of it is unusual. It just needs pricing, and a builder can only price it if they've seen the site or you've told them about it.

What's hidden until the house is opened up

Every builder prices what they can see. On an older house a lot of it isn't visible until the plaster, floorboards or tiles come off: joist ends gone soft where a wall has been damp, a lintel that's barely there, wiring that won't pass, a chimney breast with not much holding it up. On a roof job the timbers often look fine from the loft and less fine once the tiles are stripped.

A sensible quote says where these risks are and how they'll be dealt with, rather than pretending they aren't there. The usual ways are a provisional sum for the part nobody can see, an agreed rate for extra work of a known kind, or a clear note that opening up may change the price, with a promise to show you before anything extra is done.

Wildlife can matter as well. Loft conversions and roof repairs are among the jobs that can affect bats, and where a survey is needed, Natural England's advice is that it's done in the right season. A roof job enquired about in winter can end up waiting for the survey, which costs time even if it doesn't cost much money.

Looking along a long run of new rafters inside a full scaffold enclosure with a temporary roof
New rafters going in under a temporary roof, with the whole scaffold sheeted in

The cost drivers at a glance

The same nine things come up on almost every building job we price. The right-hand column is the question that gets you a straight answer from any builder.

DriverWhy it moves the priceWhat to ask your builder
DesignUnfinished drawings force guesses and allowancesWhat have you assumed that isn't on the drawings?
GroundClay, trees and old drains decide how deep and what type the footings areIs the groundwork a fixed price or a provisional sum?
StructureSteels, long spans, removed walls and temporary propsIs the steel priced from the engineer's calculations?
AccessMaterials and waste moved by hand take far longerHow will materials get in and spoil get out?
Condition of the houseRot, weak lintels and old wiring only show once it's opened upWhat happens to the price if you find something?
SpecificationBrick, glazing, roofing and kitchens vary more than labour doesWhich items are allowances, and what do they assume?
Season and lead timesWet months slow groundworks and roofs, and made-to-order items take weeksWhen could you start, and what has to be ordered first?
FeesDrawings, engineer, building control and party wall costs sit outside the buildWhich fees are in your price and which are mine?
VATThe rate depends on the type of work and whether the builder is registeredIs VAT included in this total?

Materials and specification

Two quotes for the same drawing can differ just because of what each builder assumed you'd want. Specification is where that happens. Some choices that change a price a lot: brick to match a 1930s house against a modern facing brick, plain clay tiles against concrete ones, aluminium sliders against uPVC doors, a fitted kitchen against one you've bought flat-packed.

Timber has its own grades. Structural softwood is strength graded, usually C16 or C24, and the engineer's design says which goes where. We use what the design calls for. Swapping down a grade to save a few lengths is the sort of saving that only shows when a floor bounces.

The clear way to handle anything not yet chosen is a named allowance, often called a PC sum (prime cost): a stated amount for, say, the kitchen or the floor tiles, which goes up or down with what you actually pick. Compare those allowances between quotes. A low one makes a total look smaller than it really is.

Time of year and lead times

The season changes the programme more than the price, but the programme is money. Footings in wet clay, stripped roofs and open excavations all go slower through the wettest months, roughly October to January round here. A roof can be kept working under a temporary roof on the scaffold, which costs more but stops a job stalling under tarpaulins for a week.

Lead times matter just as much. Made-to-order glazing, steel and some roofing materials can take weeks, and a job waiting on one delivery still has scaffold standing and paid for. Booking ahead doesn't always lower a price, but it lowers the risk of paying for time when nothing's happening.

The paperwork has its own clock: a planning decision, building control approval, and a party wall notice at least two months before work on a shared wall. Start those early and they won't hold the builder up.

Fees, paperwork and VAT

Some costs belong to the project, not the builder: drawings, the structural engineer, a planning or prior approval application, building control through your council's team or a registered private approver, party wall surveyors if a neighbour doesn't consent, and a build-over agreement if you're building close to a public sewer. Ask every builder which of these their quote includes, and budget for the rest.

VAT depends on the type of work. Under HMRC's VAT Notice 708:

  • building a new house is normally zero-rated
  • renovating a home that has stood empty for at least two years can qualify for the reduced 5% rate, as can a conversion that changes the number of homes in a building
  • extensions, alterations and repairs to an existing home are normally charged at the standard rate

Not every builder is VAT registered, so one quote can look lower simply because it carries no VAT. Compare totals with VAT included, and check that a builder who does charge it shows it on the quote.

How a quote handles the unknowns

A good quote is a firm price for everything that can be known, plus a clear, separate treatment of what can't. You'll usually see some mix of these:

  • Fixed price. A set price for a set scope. The builder carries the risk inside that scope, which is partly why it isn't the lowest number you'll be offered.
  • Provisional sum. An allowance for work that can't be measured yet, like footings near a tree. It's adjusted to the real cost, and it should say what it assumes.
  • PC sum. An allowance for something you haven't chosen yet, like a kitchen or tiles.
  • Contingency. Money held back for the unexpected. Some quotes include one. You can also keep your own.
  • Cost-plus or day work. You pay for time and materials as they're used. Flexible, but the risk sits with you.

Be careful with a price that doesn't commit to anything. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, if a contract doesn't fix a price or say how it's worked out, you pay a reasonable price and no more. That's a backstop, not a plan. A written price agreed before the work starts protects both sides, and extra work should be priced and agreed in writing before it's done. It's how we work.

What this means for your job

You can't get a reliable figure for building work from a web page, ours or anyone else's. You can get a reliable quote by doing the deciding first: drawings, the engineer, the finishes you want and a clear list of what you're buying yourself. Then give every builder the same information, so the quotes that come back can actually be compared.

Our guide to comparing builders' quotes shows how to line them up, and how we quote explains what goes into ours. When you're ready, send us what you have. We'll look at the site and come back with a written, itemised quote, with the unknowns shown as unknowns. You can see how a job runs with us from first visit to handover.

Sources

  1. HMRC: Buildings and construction, VAT Notice 708 (checked November 2026)
  2. legislation.gov.uk: Building Regulations 2010, Part 2A dutyholders (checked November 2026)
  3. HSE: CDM 2015 and domestic clients (checked November 2026)
  4. GOV.UK: Building regulations approval (checked November 2026)
  5. legislation.gov.uk: Party Wall etc. Act 1996, section 3 (checked November 2026)
  6. legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 51 (checked November 2026)
  7. GOV.UK: Bats, protection, surveys and licences (checked November 2026)
  8. GOV.UK: Bats, advice for making planning decisions (checked November 2026)

Want us to do it?