Start by giving every builder the same brief

You can only compare quotes that price the same job. The Federation of Master Builders recommends detailed written quotes from at least three builders, with every builder given the same information, and Citizens Advice says much the same. If one builder saw the engineer's calculations and another priced from a sketch, the gap between them tells you nothing.

Before you ask anyone, put one pack together and send it to all of them:

  • the drawings and their revision number, or a sketch with sizes
  • the structural engineer's calculations, if the job has any
  • a written list of the finishes you've chosen, and what you haven't decided yet
  • what you're buying or arranging yourself
  • photos of the site and the route in, plus any trees, drains or access problems you know about
  • when you'd like the work done

If a builder suggests doing something a different way, that can be worth hearing. Ask them to price your version as well, so you still have a like-for-like figure to set against the others.

Is it a quote or an estimate?

Check which one you're holding before you compare anything. Citizens Advice puts it simply: a quote is a fixed price, and an estimate is a rough guess that can end up higher. Plenty of documents headed "quote" are really estimates, with words like "approximately", "subject to" or "to be confirmed on site" doing a lot of the work.

Two bits of consumer law are worth knowing here. What a builder says or writes about the work, and you rely on, becomes part of the contract, which is a good reason to get promises in writing. And if the contract never fixes a price or says how it's worked out, you pay a reasonable price and no more. That sounds fair until you're the one arguing about what reasonable means.

A written, itemised price agreed before work starts is better for everybody. It's where every job we take on begins, and you can see the rest of how a job runs with us.

How to compare quotes line by line

Set aside an evening, a pen and a printout of each quote. This takes longer than looking at the totals, and it's the only part that tells you anything.

  1. Put them in the same order

    You

    Copy each quote into one table, stage by stage, with the same headings. Groundworks, structure, roof, windows and doors, first fix, plastering, second fix and finishes works for most building jobs.

  2. Check the scope against the drawings

    You

    Tick off every room, opening and item on the drawings against each quote. Anything missing is either excluded or forgotten, and you need to know which.

  3. Mark the exclusions

    You

    Write down everything each quote leaves out, then note who will do it instead. Excluded work still has to happen, and someone still has to pay for it.

  4. Line up the allowances

    You

    List every provisional sum and PC sum side by side. If one builder allows far less for the kitchen or the footings, their total isn't really lower.

  5. Compare the totals with VAT

    You

    Make sure every total includes VAT where it applies. A builder who isn't VAT registered will look cheaper on paper for that reason alone.

  6. Read the payment terms and dates

    You

    Note any deposit, the payment stages, what each payment is tied to, the start date and how long each builder expects the job to take.

  7. Ask everyone the same questions

    You

    Send one list of questions to every builder and compare the answers. How clearly and quickly they reply is part of the comparison.

A side-by-side check for three quotes

Use this as the left-hand column of your comparison. Anything in the last column isn't a reason to rule a builder out, but it is a reason to ask again.

What to checkA good quote showsAsk again if
ScopeEvery item on the drawings, priced in stagesIt's one total with a paragraph of description
DrawingsThe drawing numbers and revision it's priced fromIt doesn't say what it's based on
ExclusionsA written list of what isn't includedNothing is excluded at all
Provisional sumsEach one named, with what it covers and assumesUnknown work seems to be hidden inside the total
Allowances for finishesA stated allowance for each item not yet chosenIts allowances are far lower than the other quotes
VATThe total with VAT shown, or a clear note that none is chargedYou can't tell whether VAT is in
PaymentsStages tied to work you can seeA large share is due before work starts
ChangesHow extra work is priced and agreed in writingChanges are left to be sorted out on site
TimingsA start date and an expected length of jobThere's no date at all
Who does whatWhich trades are the builder's own and which are yoursIt's unclear who's doing the electrics or the plastering

Provisional sums, PC sums and contingency explained

These three cause most of the confusion in a quote, and most of the arguments at the end of a job.

A provisional sum is an allowance for work nobody can price exactly yet, like footings on clay near a tree, or repairs to roof timbers nobody can see until the tiles are off. It gets adjusted to the real cost. A good one says what it assumes, such as a footing depth, so you can see why it changed.

A PC sum (prime cost) is an allowance for something you haven't chosen yet, like the kitchen, the bathroom fittings or the floor tiles. Your final bill moves with what you pick.

A contingency is money set aside for the unexpected. It might be in the quote or kept in your own budget. Either is fine, as long as you know which.

Here's the trick for comparing them: ask every builder to carry the same provisional sums and the same allowances. Then the differences between quotes are in the work each one has actually priced, which is the part you're trying to compare. Be wary of a quote with no provisional sums at all on a job with obvious unknowns. Usually the risk has either been priced in quietly or ignored.

What's often left out of a builder's quote

Exclusions are normal. Every quote has an edge somewhere. The trouble is exclusions you don't notice until the work needs doing. Look out for these:

  • building control fees and the engineer's fees
  • party wall surveyors
  • skips, waste and carting away the soil from the footings
  • scaffolding, or how long it's priced to stand
  • moving drains, meters or the boiler
  • plastering and making good after the electrics and plumbing
  • decorating, flooring and fitting the kitchen
  • electrical and gas certificates, which come from the trades who do that work

None of these is a reason to turn a builder down. Write them down, find out who's doing each one, and add them to your comparison, so you're comparing finished jobs rather than whatever each builder chose to include.

VAT and the total you're owed

When you agree work at home or online, the builder has to give you the total price including taxes before you're bound, or, where it really can't be worked out in advance, how the price will be calculated. So a homeowner's quote should show a total with VAT in it, if VAT applies.

Whether it applies depends on the builder and the work. A builder who isn't VAT registered doesn't charge it. Under HMRC's VAT Notice 708, extensions and alterations to an existing home are normally standard-rated, building a new home is normally zero-rated, and some renovations of long-empty homes and some conversions can be 5%. Compare totals with VAT included, or you'll be comparing different things.

One clear warning sign, which the FMB flags too: a lower price for cash with no VAT. That isn't a discount you want any part of.

Payment stages, deposits and your right to cancel

Look at when you pay as closely as how much. Good payment terms are tied to work you can see finished, such as footings in and inspected, walls up, roof on, first fix done and completion. The FMB's advice is to never pay the whole cost of the work upfront. If a quote asks for a deposit, ask what it pays for. Materials made to measure for your job, like windows or steel, are a common and sensible reason.

If you agree the contract at home or online, you normally have 14 days to cancel. Work can only start inside that time if you ask for it, and for a contract agreed at home that request has to be in writing, though an email is enough. Cancel after work has started at your request and you may have to pay for what's been done. If the builder never told you about the right to cancel, the cancellation period can run for up to 12 months.

There are exceptions. Goods made to your measurements or design aren't covered once they're made, and contracts to build a new house sit outside these rules altogether. Citizens Advice explains the details.

Timings, building control and who's in charge

A quote without a start date and a rough length of job is missing something you'll care about. If the contract doesn't fix a time, the law only says the work has to be done within a reasonable time, which is a weak thing to rely on. Ask for a written programme, even a simple one.

Ask too who handles building control. You can use your council's building control team or a registered private approver, and private firms must be on the government's public register, where you can check them. A quote should say who makes the application and whether the fees are in the price.

Finally, if one builder is running the whole job, the client's Building Regulations and site safety duties pass to them by law. It's fair to ask how they'll plan the work and manage the other trades. A builder who's thought about it will have an answer ready.

Red flags in a builder's quote

One of these on its own might have an innocent explanation. Two or three together usually don't.

  • One total and a short paragraph, with no breakdown
  • No drawings, revision or specification named
  • Words like approximately or subject to site conditions across most of the price
  • No exclusions listed at all
  • No provisional sums on a job with obvious unknowns
  • A lower price for cash, or an offer to leave the VAT off
  • Most of the money due before any work starts
  • No start date, no programme and no written contract
  • Pressure to sign today, or a discount that ends this week

Questions to ask before you choose a builder

Send the same list to every builder on your shortlist:

  • Which drawings, calculations and specification is this price based on?
  • Which parts are fixed, and which are provisional sums or allowances?
  • What isn't included, and who would normally do it?
  • Is VAT included in the total?
  • Which trades are your own, and which will you bring in?
  • Who makes the building control application, and are the fees in this price?
  • How are changes priced and agreed?
  • When could you start, and how long should it take?
  • How long is this quote valid for?
  • Can I see jobs like mine that you've done, and check your company details?

That last question matters as much as the price. Our guide on how to check a builder before you hire covers company records, insurance and reviews you can actually trace.

What this means when you ask us to quote

We'd rather you compared our quote carefully than took it on trust. When we price a job we send a written, itemised quote for our part of the work, with the provisional sums named, the exclusions listed, and changes agreed in writing before they're done. If you're weighing ours against others, run the same checks on all of them, ours included.

For what decides the numbers in the first place, read what decides the cost of building work. For what goes into ours, read how we quote.

Sources

  1. legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013, Schedule 2 (checked November 2026)
  2. legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, regulation 36 (checked November 2026)
  3. legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, regulation 31 (checked November 2026)
  4. legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, regulation 28 (checked November 2026)
  5. legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, regulation 6 (checked November 2026)
  6. legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 50 (checked November 2026)
  7. legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 51 (checked November 2026)
  8. legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 52 (checked November 2026)
  9. HMRC: Buildings and construction, VAT Notice 708 (checked November 2026)
  10. GOV.UK: Building regulations approval (checked November 2026)
  11. GOV.UK: Find a registered building control approver in England (checked November 2026)
  12. legislation.gov.uk: Building Regulations 2010, Part 2A dutyholders (checked November 2026)
  13. Citizens Advice: Before you get building work done (checked November 2026)
  14. Citizens Advice: Cancelling building or decorating work (checked November 2026)
  15. Federation of Master Builders: How to choose a builder (checked November 2026)
  16. Federation of Master Builders: Working with your builder (checked November 2026)

Want us to do it?